Overview of the Debate: Benjen Stark and Jon Snow

Among the fervent Game of Thrones fans, the topic of whether Benjen Stark was aware of Jon Snow's true identity is a subject of intense discussion. This article will explore the arguments for and against the theory that Benjen knew the truth, as well as delve into the family dynamics that make this question intriguing.

Arguments for Benjen Being Aware

Family Loyalty

Benjen Stark, as a member of the House Stark, would have a strong sense of loyalty to his family. Since Jon Snow is the son of Lyanna Stark, it is plausible that Benjen recognized the importance of protecting Jon's identity. His loyalty to his family, especially after Lyanna's tragic death, would have motivated him to safeguard the secret if he knew it.

Knowledge of Lyanna's Situation

Benjen was likely privy to the circumstances surrounding Jon's birth. He was close to both Eddard and Lyanna, making it reasonable to assume he knew about the promise Eddard made to protect Jon. His role at the Wall, where he spent a significant amount of time, made him a key figure in the Stark family's affairs.

Protective Nature

Benjen's role as a Night's Watch member required him to be vigilant about the safety of the North. Understanding the dangers Jon faced, Benjen might have known the true identity of Jon Snow due to Eddard's secrecy about Lyanna's relationship with Rhaegar Targaryen.

Arguments Against Benjen Being Aware

Lack of Evidence

The show and books do not provide direct evidence that Benjen knew about Jon's parentage. The narrative focuses more on Eddard Stark's promise and the implications of Jon being a Stark, rather than on the knowledge of other characters like Benjen.

Eddard's Secrecy

Eddard Stark was extremely secretive about Jon's parentage, believing that this information needed to be protected to ensure Jon's safety. It is plausible that he kept this information from even his closest family members, including Benjen.

Narrative Focus

The story often emphasizes Eddard's journey and the importance of Jon as a Stark. The narrative does not suggest that other characters, such as Benjen, were aware of the truth, thus reinforcing the idea that Benjen's focus was on his duties at the Wall rather than Jon's true identity.

Further Evidence from the Series

Benjen and Lyanna's Relationship

The relationship between Benjen and Lyanna is critical in understanding potential motivations. They were very close as children and young adults, as seen in Bran's vision of them sword fighting in secret. Benjen's presence at Lyanna's side during her difficult moments suggests a strong bond and shared secrets.

Secrets and Teasing

Lyanna's reaction to Benjen teasing her about Rhaegar is significant. Pouring wine over his head was a bold and personal action, confirming that Lyanna knew Benjen understood her feelings. This close dynamic makes it plausible that Benjen knew about their secret.

Benjen's Joining the Night's Watch

Benjen's decision to join the Night's Watch is complex. Some speculate that he believed Jon should have been the heir, seeing Eddard as stealing his birthright. Others think Eddard forced Benjen to take the black, possibly for helping Lyanna and Rhaegar. Regardless, Benjen's decision aligns with his loyalty to the family and the North.

Deadpan Reactions at the King's Feast

At the King's feast in Winterfell, Benjen's comment to Jon, "wish that you were," implies that Benjen knew who Jon's true father was. This subtle remark suggests that Benjen would have treated Jon differently if he did not recognize him as a Stark.

Ultimately, the ambiguity in the narrative leaves room for interpretation. Fans continue to discuss and theorize about the motivations and knowledge of various characters in the series, whether it be Benjen Stark or others, making the Game of Thrones world endlessly fascinating.