Why Do Some of the Most Educated Bollywood Actors Star in Non-Sense Movies?

In the vibrant world of Bollywood, many educated actors find themselves playing roles in what are perceived as nonsensical or masala films. The driving force behind these choices is often multifaceted, and reflects the complex dynamics of the film industry. This article delves into the various reasons behind this phenomenon, exploring the role of commercial success, friendship, and the desire to broaden their acting range.

Commercial Success: A Key Factor

One of the primary reasons actors choose to star in non-sense movies is the promise of commercial success. The Indian audience, especially in tier 2 and 3 cities, often has a penchant for melodramatic and fantastical storylines. Bollywood is well-known for creating movies that cater to these tastes, leading actors to accept these roles to stay relevant and in the public eye. As one Bollywood actor, Arjun, explains, "I do what pays the bill. If a movie sells and people love it, I am fine with taking on any kind of role." This commercial success often translates into more offers, potentially leading to a larger fan base and a more stable career.

Friendship and Collaboration

Friendship plays a significant role in many casting decisions within Bollywood. Actors, directors, and producers often form deep personal relationships that can influence casting choices. For instance, Shah Rukh Khan, one of the most famous Bollywood actors, has worked extensively with director Farah Khan. Their professional and personal relationship has led to multiple collaborations on movies such as 'Om Shanti Om' and 'Happy New Year,' which many consider nonsensical. This dynamic is not limited to this example; many actors are drawn to work with their friends or directors they trust, even if the end product is not always well-received by everyone.

Experimentation and Genre Diversity

Another reason actors venture into non-sense movies is the desire to explore different genres and challenge themselves. Bollywood has a wide array of subgenres ranging from romance to action to comedy, and actors like to experiment with different styles. For instance, an actor might decide to take on a role in a highly commercial film to test their performance boundaries or to try something completely different. This experimental approach can sometimes backfire, leading to critically and commercially underwhelming movies, but it is also an opportunity for growth and innovation in the industry.

Producer-Driven Decisions

On the production side, movies are ultimately made for the audience. Producers carefully consider what will resonate with the largest possible audience, often prioritizing storylines that will sell well. Sometimes actors, despite their education and sophistication, may not fully grasp the comedic elements or the nonsensical plot points until after they've committed to the project. This was the case with Shashi Kapoor, who, despite his film-making education and influence from foreign cinema, had to settle for roles in what he perceived as non-sense movies after his initial efforts to bring a more sophisticated style to Bollywood were thwarted.

Industry Attitudes Towards Non-Sense Films

It's worth noting that the industry itself has a certain attitude towards films that don't conform to traditional narrative structures. Movies like 'Manjhi: Masaan' and 'Mirghat with a Straw' are often seen as box office disappointments, even when they receive critical acclaim. On the other hand, films that align with mainstream tastes, such as 'Kick,' tend to be more commercially successful. This dichotomy highlights the tension between artistic integrity and commercial viability in Bollywood.

Conclusion

The decision to star in non-sense movies is a multifaceted one that takes into account personal aspirations, commercial realities, and the desires of the audience. While some actors may regret their choices, these roles often provide valuable opportunities for growth and exposure. The complex landscape of Bollywood requires actors to strike a balance between staying true to their artistic vision and meeting the demands of the industry. Ultimately, the success or failure of these movies is a reflection not just of the actors' careers but of the broader cultural and economic forces shaping the film industry.