Assessing the Impact: Would Scott Buck's Involvement Boost the Tomatometer Scores of Iron Fist and Inhumans?

Scott Buck, a prominent figure in television production, has had a significant impact on the content and ratings of shows under his watch. However, how would his involvement have affected the Tomatometer score of two critically acclaimed series, Iron Fist and Inhumans?

Pre-existing Challenges and Critiques

Both Iron Fist and Inhumans faced inherent challenges that may have impacted their ratings and reception. Iron Fist, especially, was perceived as a weaker standalone series due to its reliance on the Luke Cage character. Similarly, the Inhumans dealt with complex and controversial themes, such as eugenics and royalty with a history of problematic practices.

Leading and Editing Differences

Scott Buck’s involvement, or lack thereof, in these shows could have led to vastly different outputs. For instance, the second season of Iron Fist, which was run by M. Raven Metzner, was reportedly much improved. This suggests that Buck's expertise could have been crucial in enhancing the quality of both series.

Evaluating the Tomatometer Score

The Tomatometer is an aggregate score reflecting positive reviews from multiple professional critics. Giving a fresh Tomatometer score to Iron Fist and Inhumans without Buck would be speculative, as it necessitates an understanding of audience and critical reception.

Compared to Other Series

Given the parallel success of Iron Fist and The Defenders, it's reasonable to assume that a similar Tomatometer score might be in play. However, there are multiple factors that contribute to these scores, including critical reception, audience engagement, and thematic depth.

Potential Improvements with Scors Buck's Involvement

Iron Fist

One of the most glaring issues with Iron Fist was the casting of Finn Jones, who lacked martial arts experience. By identifying this gap and addressing it through proper training and casting, the series might have been more internally consistent and engaging.

Inhumans

The introduction of Inhumans without adequately explaining the Royal Family's history and background could have alienated both new and returning audiences. Concepts such as the Moon Base and the uncertainty surrounding the Chrysalis Experiment could have been more clearly explained, enhancing the overall narrative coherence.

Conclusion

While it is challenging to quantitatively assess the specific impact of Scott Buck's potential involvement, his expertise in many cases has led to improvements in the quality and reception of television shows. As seen in the second season of Iron Fist, his guidance could potentially elevate these series to even greater heights.

Would these changes have significantly altered the Tomatometer scores? That is a debatable question, but they certainly would have enhanced the critical and audience reception of these shows. The shows could have been more coherent, relatable, and engaging, thus potentially leading to higher scores.