Could Arya Stark Be a Secret Targaryen?

The idea that Arya Stark could be a Secret Targaryen is a fascinating fan theory that has captured the imaginations of many fans, despite lacking substantial support from the source material. While numerous theories exist, this particular one presents a compelling case, blending fan theories with in-game events in a way that adds an intriguing layer to Arya's character.

Parentage and Appearance

Parentage:

Arya Stark is explicitly identified as the daughter of Eddard Ned Stark and Catelyn Stark, with no indication in the source material suggesting any alternate parentage. This establishes a strong foundation for her identity as a Stark.

Targaryen Traits:

Targaryens are known for distinct traits like silver hair and a proficiency with dragons. Despite extensive time at Winterfell and the presence of the hotsprings suggested to be powered by a sleeping dragon, Arya does not manifest these characteristics. Her outward appearance aligns more closely with the Stark lineage, which is marked by raven-black hair. Additionally, Catelyn has no known encounters with Targaryens, further negating the possibility of Arya being a Targaryen.

Narrative and Character Arc

Arya’s Character Arc:

Arya's journey throughout the series is centered around her identity as a Stark and her quest for vengeance and self-discovery. Introducing a Targaryen lineage would significantly complicate her narrative, requiring substantial buildup and foreshadowing to have any impact. Without this, any claim of Targaryen heritage feels disjointed and unsupported.

RLJ Theory:

The more prominent theory regarding secret Targaryens involves Jon Snow, who is believed to be the true heir to the Iron Throne, being the son of Lyanna Stark and Rhaegar Targaryen. This theory has substantial textual support and is more relevant to the overarching plot of the Game of Thrones narrative.

Authors' Intent and Lore

George R.R. Martin:

Founder of Westeros, George R.R. Martin has crafted a complex world with intricately woven family dynamics. While surprises and twists are common in his narratives, Arya being a Targaryen seems unlikely given the established lore. The Arryn and Targaryen families have intertwined in significant ways, but there is no evidence to suggest that the Starks share this lineage.

Theories and Speculation

While it is entertaining to explore the idea of Arya being a secret Targaryen, the evidence from the source material does not support such a claim. Arya's story is deeply rooted in her identity as a Stark. Any assertion of Targaryen ancestry would require significant narrative justification that is currently absent.

Conclusion: While fan theories can be intriguing, they must be balanced against the established narrative and source material. Character development and plot progression in A Song of Ice and Fire and Game of Thrones are tightly woven, and adding an unexplained Targaryen heritage to Arya Stark would be difficult to integrate convincingly.