Arthur's Discovery of Merlin's True Identity in BBC’s Merlin

When Arthur discovers Merlin’s true identity, it comes as a significant shock. This revelation, which occurs in the penultimate episode of the series, marks a pivotal moment in the dynamics between the two characters. It's a transformation that takes time for Arthur to embrace fully, as he grapples with the notion that his trusted advisor and compatriot is not just a mere servant or an ordinary warlock, but Dragoon the Great, also known as Emrys. This discovery is not only a turning point in their lifelong relationship but also in the interpretation of the narrative, adding layers of complexity to the story.

The Misconception: Arthur Underestimates Merlin

Arthur's journey with Merlin is fraught with misunderstandings and misinterpretations. One of the significant flaws of Arthur towards Merlin is his initial underestimation of his abilities. Early in the series, Arthur views Merlin as nothing more than a loyal servant and, despite their evolving friendship, he often considers Merlin merely as a tool for his own advancement rather than recognizing him as an equal or a powerful ally. This mindset is evident in Arthur’s perception of Merlin's actions and contributions, where Arthur assumes that his achievements are wholly due to his own talent and smarts. This underestimation persists until the moment of revelation in the penultimate episode, where the truth finally comes to light, and the significance of Merlin's role in Arthur’s life is acknowledged.

Merlin’s Secret and the Threat of Being Exposed

The depth of Merlin’s deception runs even deeper than the surface-level discoveries. It goes beyond the naked truth of his identity; Merlin has kept this secret not only because of his magical nature but also due to the very real and dire consequences of exposure. Specifically, if Uther knew about Merlin’s true identity, he would likely order his execution. This is not a frivolous claim; Arthur himself, despite his loyalty to Merlin, would likely be bound by his oaths and sense of duty to inform his father of the truth. Understandably, the stakes are extremely high, and Merlin must tread carefully to protect himself and, ultimately, Arthur from the wrath of Uther.

Emrys and the Implications for Arthur

The identity of Merlin as Emrys, the legendary sorcerer, holds significant implications for Arthur. It means that Merlin possesses unparalleled magical power and knowledge that could make an invaluable ally in numerous situations. Emrys is not just a powerful warlock but a figure whose legend has spread across time, making him revered by many and feared by others. Arthur’s recognition of this new reality forces him to reassess his relationship with Merlin and his perceptions of the battles they face together. It places an unprecedented weight on their alliance, as Arthur now understands that his survival and eventual kingship are intricately tied to Merlin’s magical prowess.

Conclusion: A New Era for Arthur and Merlin

The revelation that Arthur makes about Merlin’s true identity marks a new era in their relationship. No longer can Arthur see Merlin as just a servant, no longer can he deny the profound impact that Merlin has had on his life and his quest for honor and power. The discovery of Emrys’ identity forces a shift in perspective, allowing Arthur to embrace his closest friend and ally in a way he never thought possible. Though the journey ahead will undoubtedly be fraught with challenges, the acknowledgment of Merlin’s true identity is a crucial step towards their continued partnership and the fulfillment of their destinies.