Are the Actors in ‘Top Gun’ 1986 a Realistic Representation of Navy Pilots? Do They Behave as Shown?

It is often tempting to seek and find military accuracy in films, especially when these films become cult classics like Top Gun. However, when it comes to Top Gun and its portrayal of Navy pilots, it would be a mistake to look for realistic representations here, let alone to use the film as a reference for how real Navy pilots behave.

Why Movies Aren't Real

Action movies, as entertaining as they are, are not meant to be accurate portrayals of military procedures and protocols. The primary goal of these films is to engage viewers with thrilling and dramatic storytelling, achieve high action sequences, and deliver blockbuster entertainment. These goals often come into conflict with the need for precision and realism, especially when it comes to military depictions.

‘Top Gun’ and its Characters

Top Gun, released in 1986, tells the story of a young Naval Aviator, Lieutenant Rick "Maverick" McKee, under the mentorship of experienced pilot and flight instructor Lieutenant Commander " Goes Around" Scott. While the film's portrayal of Navy pilots, their training, and their lifestyles are often praised for its charismatic and adventurous portrayal, it is important to note the deviations from reality.

Real Navy Pilots vs. Film Characters

One of the most prominent discrepancies between the film and reality is the depiction of aircraft and their capabilities. In Top Gun, the characters fly in sleek and flashy F-14 Tomcats, performing a wide range of advanced maneuvers that seem almost too realistic, if not slightly excessive. In reality, Navy pilots primarily fly a variety of aircraft, including the F/A-18 Hornet, and their training focuses on the practical aspects of flying these machines in combat scenarios.

The Misbehavior of Maverick

Chuck Norris, the co-star, rightly pointed out in the film's making-of documentary that the concept of a pilot like Lieutenant "Maverick" would be almost absurd in real life. Maverick disregards commands, is disrespectful to his superiors, and even ends up ejecting from the cockpit mid-mission. These behaviors are not reflective of the discipline and adherence to protocol expected of real Navy pilots.

Training and Preparation

In reality, becoming a Navy pilot involves rigorous training, discipline, and a deep understanding of the operational procedures. The Navy takes the training of its pilots very seriously, emphasizing safety, teamwork, and a high level of professionalism. These qualities are drilled into pilots through demanding and intense training programs, preparing them for the challenges and responsibilities of combat.

Conclusion

While Top Gun is undoubtedly an entertaining and visually stunning film, it is essential to remember that its primary purpose is to provide an adventurous and thrilling cinematic experience. The portrayal of Navy pilots in the film, complete with the rebellious and overconfident character of Maverick, is not a realistic representation. For those seeking accurate depictions of Navy pilots and their training, it is crucial to turn to official military resources, such as recruitment videos and training manuals, rather than relying on fictional films for such information.

So, while watching Top Gun or similar films for the sheer joy of suspension of disbelief is perfectly fine, it's important to approach them with a critical eye when it comes to expecting them to illustrate real-life military practices accurately.