Analyzing Plot Holes in the Original Planet of the Apes Movie

The original 1968 film, Planet of the Apes, is a classic of its time, but like many well-loved works, it is not without its flaws. Perhaps the most glaring issue is the intrinsic logic that seems to have been overlooked by its characters. While many fans and critics may marvel at the grand scope and iconic imagery of the film, there are significant plot holes that could have been addressed at the time.

Noticing Constellations and the Moon

One of the most notable plot holes in the original film involves the lunar observation. When Taylor and his fellow astronauts land on what they believe to be Earth, they fail to notice the astronomical discrepancies that could have revealed the truth. The astronauts set up a telescope to study the night sky. Under normal circumstances, they should have immediately recognized the constellations and the phase of the Moon as being different, especially if this was supposed to be the future Earth.

The Moon, which has a distinct shape and phase in our night sky, would be a key point of observation. It is surprising that the leading scientists on board, with the necessary instruments to study celestial bodies, did not make the connection. This detail could easily have reshaped the story into a more coherent narrative, especially given the advanced technology supposed to be present in this future world.

Language Inconsistency: A Dead Giveaway

Another significant plot hole revolves around the presence of human-like apes speaking English. In the film, the apes are depicted as being highly advanced and technologically adept. It stands to reason that, if humans had evolved into intelligent beings and communicated with each other, the language would not be English, but more likely a language native to Earth in the year 3000.

The ability for afoot soldiers to casually communicate in English with Taylor and the others is anachronistic. Moreover, the apes should have some form of language that might align with their cultural and temporal context. The narrative tension and intrigue could have been amplified by making the language an artificial construct or a translated form of English, reflecting the advanced technology of their society.

Conclusion and Reflection

While many viewers appreciate the timeless themes and unique science fiction approach of Planet of the Apes, these plot holes underscore the importance of narrative consistency and attention to detail in film production. Understanding why these inconsistencies arise can provide valuable insight for aspiring filmmakers and writers.

The original film remains a thrilling and thought-provoking classic, and these plot holes, while evident, do not detract from its enduring appeal. They serve as reminders of the challenges filmmakers face in crafting a coherent and believable narrative within the scope of their imagination and creative vision.

Keywords: Planet of the Apes, plot hole, constellations, language inconsistency