Analyze and Rank: The Best Episode of Black Mirror Season 4

Black Mirror, the critically acclaimed series created by Charlie Brooker, has been a constant source of thought-provoking narratives that explore the dark side of technology and society. In its fourth season, several episodes stand out for their unique visions and critiques. In this article, we will analyze and rank each episode of Black Mirror Season 4 to determine the best one and provide reasons for our choices.

1. USS Callister

USS Callister is an episode that takes a comedic approach to a serious theme, making it both enjoyable and humorous. However, it falls short in several aspects, including its reliance on overused plot elements and unresolved technical flaws.

Analysis:

MIxed with classic elements inspired by White Christmas, the episode references well-known science fiction, adding a layer of familiarity for fans of the genre. The theme of virtual simulations, while interesting, can feel derivative and detracts from the drama of the series as a whole. The predictability of the plot is a downside, especially when compared to the unpredictable nature of other Black Mirror episodes. The final outcome is overly positive and lacks the sudden twists that are a hallmark of the series.

While the episode is entertaining, it has significant flaws. A genetic sample cannot recreate a person's conscience instantly, making the episode's premise unsustainable. This tech fails to meet real-world scientific standards, which detracts from the experience. Nonetheless, the humor and the overall entertainment value are worth mentioning.

Final Rating:

7.5

2. Arkangel

Arkangel is a thoughtfully crafted episode with an original concept, though it suffers from being overly personal. The narrative focuses on a mother whose actions against a tracking system are seen as extremes by the rest of the society.

Analysis:

With a distinctive and original idea, the episode grabs the viewer's attention right from the start. The ending, while exaggerated, provides a powerful message about the invasion of privacy and the unintended consequences of technology. The episode highlights the personal conflict and ethical dilemmas faced by the main characters.

Nonetheless, the personal nature of the storyline might make it feel too focused on the individual's struggles rather than the broader societal issue.

Final Rating:

8.5

3. Crocodile

Crocodile features a visually beautiful and well-constructed storyline that is true to the essence of Black Mirror. However, it has a slight flaw that detracts from its overall impact.

Analysis:

The episode is built around impressive visual effects and a strong narrative that keeps the viewer engaged. The technology used in the episode has potential but is underutilized, reducing the impact of certain plot points. The characterizations are generally strong, but the tightness of the storyline could be improved.

The episode's technical prowess is commendable, but a few minor issues with character development and plot structure make it slightly less impactful.

Final Rating:

8.5 / 8.75

4. Hang the DJ

Hang the DJ is a disappointing episode that tries to explore the same themes as other episodes in the series but fails to deliver a compelling narrative. The use of a simulation theme, which has been used too often and too predictably, does not make up for the weak storytelling.

Analysis:

The episode’s reliance on a tired theme of simulations raises expectations that are not met, as the technology takes a backseat to an anticlimactic ending. Comparatively, the storytelling in this episode is less engaging than even some of the less acclaimed episodes in Black Mirror. The comparison to San Junipero, one of the most beloved episodes, serves to emphasize the disappointment in the overall quality of this episode.

The ending, which reveals the simulation to be a simple dating app, falls flat and does not provide the unsettling or thought-provoking impact that Black Mirror is known for.

Final Rating:

7

5. Metalhead

Metalhead, often criticized as the weakest episode of the series, is a disappointing viewing experience. The plot, focused on a woman escaping from robotic dogs, is underdeveloped and lacks substance or deeper meaning.

Analysis:

The storyline is overly simplistic, relying on the absurdity of a plot that doesn't progress logically. Character development is minimal and superficial, lacking the depth needed to make the story compelling. Technical flaws, such as the unrealistic capabilities of the robotic dogs and the unconvincing suicide mission, further diminish the episode's effectiveness.

The only redeeming qualities are the direction and cinematography, which while good, do not save the episode from being a low point for the series.

Final Rating:

5

Conclusion

After careful consideration of each episode, it is clear that Black Museum stands out as the best episode of Black Mirror Season 4. This episode not only excels in its storytelling and visual elements but also pays homage to the past episodes in a powerful way. With three well-crafted stories that intertwine seamlessly, and a memorable ending, it encapsulates the essence of what makes Black Mirror so compelling.

While USS Callister offers a mix of humor and social commentary, Arkangel delivers a fresh and personal narrative, and Crocodile features impressive visuals, Black Museum is the standout episode of the season. Metalhead, on the other hand, fails to deliver on both content and execution.