Analysis of Unrealistic Elements in 'Logan': A Critical Review

The 2017 superhero film 'Logan' has been widely lauded for its emotional depth and exploration of loss, legacy, and the human condition. However, beneath its poignant narrative lies an array of plot elements that raise questions about their plausibility and veracity. This article delves into the top five inaccuracies in the movie 'Logan' and discusses their impact on the overall viewer experience.

Mutant Population Decline

The film's portrayal of mutants as nearly extinct raises concern among viewers and may stretch the boundaries of believability. Unlike previous X-Men films, where mutants were an integral part of society, 'Logan' suggests a sudden and dramatic decline in their numbers. This significant departure from previous narratives leaves some questions unanswered. For instance, the concept of a sudden decline in mutant births or their reproductive capacity is not fully explained. While the film's narrative benefits from the heightened emotional impact of this scenario, it leaves viewers questioning the scientific and logical consistency of this plot point.

Wolverine's Aging and Health

The film's portrayal of an older and more vulnerable Wolverine is a critical part of its emotional resonance. However, the extent of his physical decline and the effects of adamantium poisoning may be somewhat exaggerated. Wolverine's healing factor, a hallmark of his character, is often depicted as a near-infinite regenerative ability. Yet, the way the film shows his deterioration within such a short time frame is difficult to reconcile with the established rule of his immortality. The cause of his declining health due to adamantium poisoning is not clearly defined, leaving viewers with a sense of uncertainty.

Laura's Abilities

Promenading as the young and formidable X-23, Laura exhibits extraordinary abilities and combat skills that can seem exaggerated for a child of her age. While her genetic engineering undoubtedly plays a role, the film pushes the boundaries of plausibility by showing her to be an expert in combat and survival at an incredibly young age. The filmmakers may have chosen to emphasize her exceptional capabilities to enhance the emotional impact and provide a formidable antagonist for Wolverine. However, this portrayal stretches the limits of believability, leaving some viewers with lingering doubts about the realism of her character development.

The Reavers

The Reavers, a group of highly organized and effective cyborg mercenaries, present a technologically advanced and seemingly unassailable force. Their depiction as a formidable enemy for Wolverine adds to the film's tension and drama. However, the scale of their capabilities and the ease with which they operate within the narrative may stretch the bounds of believability. In the real world, a group of mercenaries, no matter how well-organized, would struggle to overpower a being like Wolverine, who has the near-limitless ability to regenerate and recover from damage. This aspect of the film, while thrilling, may not hold up to closer scrutiny.

The Final Confrontation

The climactic battle between Logan and the Reavers, particularly the ease with which Laura takes on multiple heavily armed foes, can feel unrealistic. While Laura is depicted as a formidable fighter, the odds against her and the others are so improbable that it may detract from the narrative's coherence. The film's focus on the emotional and thematic aspects of the story is admirable, but these highly improbable scenarios may undermine the suspension of disbelief required for a successful film experience.

The Top Five Inaccuracies in the Movie Logan

Mutants' existence: It is inaccurately portrayed that mutants 'exist' the way the film suggests. In reality, all the people who appeared to be mutants were actually Hollywood actors being paid in secret. Corporation Transigen: While it bears a resemblance to a real corporation, Transigen is actually a fictitious entity created to evade lawsuits. Future portrayal: The future depicted in the film doesn't align with present-day events, indicating that the scriptwriters created their version of the future without consulting real-world predictions. Background music: The music heard in the film is not realistic, as it was added post-production to evoke emotions and atmosphere. Adantium: The fictional metal in the film, which has damaged Wolverine's healing powers, does not exist. It's named similarly to real elements yet is a fictional substance.

While these inaccuracies may detract from the film's verisimilitude, they are integral to the emotional and thematic depth of 'Logan.' The film's ability to focus on aging, loss, and legacy is a testament to its strength as a work of art, even if some plot elements stretch the limits of believability.

As the cinematic universe continues to expand, it is hoped that future superhero films will strive for a more accurate representation of their characters and storylines.