Analysis of Unrealistic Elements in Breaking Bad

Breaking Bad, one of the most critically acclaimed television series, is renowned for its deep exploration of themes and its morally complex characters. However, even in a show that is considered a model of production, certain plot elements can strain the viewer's suspension of disbelief. Let's delve into some of the most glaringly unrealistic plot points and how they impact the overall realism of the series.

Walter's Rapid Rise to Drug Lord and Overpowered Law Enforcement Rivalry

One of the most criticized aspects of the show is Walter White's rapid transformation from a high school chemistry teacher to a feared drug lord. His ability to outsmart law enforcement and rival gangs, coupled with the fact that even his own partners often seem to be outmaneuvered, can come across as overly convenient. This not only makes the plot feel implausible but also stretches the viewer's belief in the realism of the events portrayed.

The Bank Vault Scene

Almost everyone who has watched Breaking Bad has had a moment where they find themselves questioning the logic of a particular scene. For many, it is the scene where the lawyer is inside the bank vault, depositing money while the DEA agents stand outside in the open doorway. This scene is especially egregious for its complete disregard of the legal and logistical impossibilities. Such a situation would almost certainly require a warrant and probable cause, yet the show does not provide any such justification. This lack of realism diminishes the overall credibility of the episode.

walter becomes heisenberg

A more emotional and ethical element that strikes many viewers as unrealistic is the moment when Walter becomes Heisenberg. In the scene where he watches Jane die and deliberately allows her to die, viewers find it hard to reconcile with the character's actions. The ethical dilemma here is compounded when he then tells Jesse, his partner, about this tragic event, using it as a tool to harm Jesse emotionally. This scene is not a technical plothole but an ethically questionable and emotionally charged moment that challenges the viewer's understanding of Walter's character and his actions.

Lucius Gale Jr. as a DEA mole

Another less immediate but intriguing plot point is the idea of SAC Ramey being the mole for Gus Fring in the DEA. Ramey's repeated efforts to stop Hank from pursuing Mike, despite the obvious risks, could have provided a clever twist to the narrative. Instead, this potential mole could have offered a deeper exploration of the DEA's internal workings and provided more strategic depth to the antagonists.

The Nazis in the desert shootout

A more action-oriented and technical plothole occurs during the desert shootout. In this scene, Hank and Gomez are shown as almost entirely unsuccessful in their efforts to engage the enemy. Hank, known for his exceptional marksmanship in previous episodes, is unable to hit any of the Nazis, and Gomez, operating a shotgun, fails to take down even one of the three men. This sequence defies the known abilities and experiences of the characters, making the events in the scene feel like a stretch of disbelief for many viewers.

The escape from New Hampshire to New Mexico

The journey from New Hampshire to New Mexico, especially following a manhunt, is another moment that challenges the show's realism. In this sequence, Walt gets into a car whose keys fall into his lap, and despite the presence of a manhunt, he manages to travel half a country, refueling along the way, all without being detected. This stretch of credibility is less about the practical logistics and more about maintaining the tension and drama of the scene.

Encounters and Intrusions

Another series of events that challenge the viewer's suspension of disbelief are the multiple moments where Walt encounters or intrudes into situations without any detection. His interactions with Badger, his secret meetings with Skyler in their house, and even his frisk by the Nazis, all seem to lack the logical consistency that real-life interactions would require. This is not just a plot hole but a broader issue of the show's commitment to factual realism. Whether it's the ease with which Walt is able to disguise his presence, the disregard for security checks, or the implausible success of his escapes, these elements contribute to a growing sense of suspension for the audience.

While Breaking Bad is celebrated for its intricate plot developments and character arcs, it's worth noting that even in a highly acclaimed show, certain elements can feel over-the-top or unrealistic. The balance between maintaining suspense and delivering believable narrative demands careful attention to detail. Identifying and addressing such plot points can enhance the overall viewer experience, making for a more engaging and immersive viewing experience.