Analysis: Who Would Win in a Fight Between DOFP Quicksilver (Early 1960s) and MCU Quicksilver?

The debate over whether DOFP Quicksilver from the early 1960s 616 comics or MCU Quicksilver is the superior entity raises numerous questions. After a thorough analysis of their respective capabilities, it becomes clear that MCU Quicksilver emerges as the victor.

Combat Capacities and Analysis

The winner is clearly MCU Quicksilver. Early 616 Quicksilver was known for his Mach 15 speed. In contrast, DofP Quicksilver, who is more of a backup figure, demonstrates his capabilities against Magneto's bullets during the iconic sequence from Days of Future Past. However, when compared to the events in the MCU, DofP Quicksilver would fall short.

Speed and Durability

Early 616 Quicksilver had a top speed of Mach 1 to 5, while DofP Quicksilver managed to run through a room in a single second, covering a distance of over 53 meters. This equates to a stunning speed of Mach 3,326. In comparison, MCU Quicksilver's speed is even more extraordinary, as he appeared frozen in time during key scenes, indicating a speed far beyond Mach 3,326.

Real-Time vs. Quicksilver Time

In the Days of Future Past scene, the guards were 2.63 meters away from the mutants, and the scene lasted for 83 seconds in the film, equating to 0.0000236 seconds in real-time. During the scene, Quicksilver covered a distance of 53.155 meters. Using the formula v d/t, Quicksilver's speed is calculated to be 2.26 million meters per second, or Mach 3283.27. In contrast, the maximum speed for DCEU Superman is slightly faster than this but still far from MCU Quicksilver's level.

High Speed and Durability in Combat

On the other hand, MCU Quicksilver showcases remarkable durability and striking power. In Avengers: Age of Ultron, he was able to shatter Ultron bots and even stagger Thor. This level of strength and resistance to bullet impacts far surpasses that of early 616 Quicksilver, who struggled with battlefield bullets and seemed to tire easily. Additionally, DCEU Quicksilver, despite his apparent strength, was rendered helpless against an Ultronbot, which is a stark contrast to MCU Quicksilver's prowess.

Metabolic and Cellular Activity

The early 616 Quicksilver's metabolism increases, allowing for rapid cellular activity and higher oxygen consumption. This metabolic stress could lead to cellular fatigue, explaining his slower movements towards the end of his lifespan. Determining the exact extent of his fatigue might explain why he succumbed to a stray bullet while protecting Hawkeye and a kid, indicating a gradual decrease in his overall combat effectiveness.

Conclusion

In conclusion, while early 616 Quicksilver was formidable, MCU Quicksilver's advanced speed, durable strength, and extended endurance make him the superior entity. The events in Days of Future Past and Avengers: Age of Ultron provide enough evidence to support this conclusion. Therefore, if the current context were taken into account, MCU Quicksilver would undoubtedly prevail.