Why Do Anakin and Mace Windu Hate Each Other in Star Wars?

The relationship between Anakin Skywalker and Mace Windu in the Star Wars prequels, especially in Episode III: Revenge of the Sith, is often perceived as a source of conflict and hostility. However, this perception is largely a fantasy created by fans seeking drama. In reality, the pair never truly hated each other. This essay delves into the complicated relationship, exploring the factors that created tension and the erroneous perception of animosity.

Complicated Relationship and Tension

Though many fans describe Anakin and Mace Windu as enemies, their relationship in the Star Wars universe is not rooted in mutual hate. Instead, their dynamic is characterized by a series of factors that contribute to tension and disagreement, rather than outright enmity.

Philosophical Divide

One of the primary sources of friction between Anakin and Mace Waru is their differing philosophies. Mace Windu represents the strict adherence to the Jedi Order's Code and its principles, including a strong reluctance to embrace emotions. On the other hand, Anakin faces internal struggles with his emotions and attachments, particularly regarding Padmé Amidala. This philosophical divide creates significant tension between the two.

Mistrust and Distrust

Mace Windu views Anakin's potential for darkness with concern. This mistrust stems from Windu's belief in Anakin's susceptibility to the temptations of the dark side, especially as Anakin's bond with Chancellor Palpatine deepens. Palpatine is secretly manipulating Anakin, and Windu doubts Anakin's loyalty and ability to resist this influence.

Anakin's Frustration and Resentment

Anakin often feels sidelined and distrust by the Jedi Council, including Mace Windu. This sense of being overlooked intensifies Anakin's resentment towards Windu, as Windu is a prominent member of the Council. Anakin's frustration creates a rift between the two, even as they share a deeper connection and understanding of the greater forces at play.

Climactic Conflict in Episode III: Revenge of the Sith

The climax of their relationship occurs in Episode III: Revenge of the Sith. Mace confronts Palpatine, believing that Anakin's loyalty lies with the Jedi. Anakin, desperate to save Palpatine, who he believes can help him save Padmé, intervenes. This leads to a tragic and fatal confrontation between Anakin and Mace, sealing the impression of hostility between them in the fans' minds.

Analysis of Fan Perceptions and Misconceptions

Many fans perceive Mace Windu as treating Anakin with disdain and a lack of empathy. However, this perspective is often misguided. While Windu's approach to Anakin and other individuals can come across as callous, there are underlying reasons for his behavior. Windu views his role as a Jedi with a strict and principled lens, which sometimes conflicts with Anakin's more emotional and pragmatic outlook.

Moreover, Mace Windu's treatment of Anakin and Ahsoka (another young Jedi) might have seemed contemptuous to Anakin's eyes. The canon book Brotherhood revealed that Anakin felt that Windu was treating people like pawns and objects. Anakin, feeling undervalued and overshadowed, resented Windu's authoritative and seemingly disinterested approach to leadership.

It is hypothesized that if Mace Windu had been more empathetic and understanding of Anakin's role as the Chosen One, their relationship might have been less strained. Anakin's importance as the Chosen One was more than just being a celebrity among the Jedi; it was a critical and meaningful prophecy. Windu's lack of care for this aspect of Anakin's life likely contributed to Anakin's sense of isolation and resentment.

Conclusion

The perception of Anakin and Mace Windu as enemies in Star Wars is a fan-created notion, not a reflection of their true relationship within the story. While their dynamic is complex and often fraught with tension, it stems from differing philosophies, mistrust, and frustration rather than true hatred. Understanding the nuances of their relationship provides a deeper appreciation for the rich and multifaceted world of Star Wars.