Anachronisms in Movies and TV Shows: Objects That Shouldn't Be There

Introduction to Anachronisms in Media

Countless anachronisms can be found in movies and TV shows, often creating a disconnect between the narrative and historical accuracy. These errors, while sometimes used for comedic effect or to appeal to modern audiences, can be jarring for viewers who are well-versed in the historical context. In this article, we will explore some of the most notable anachronisms that feature in period pieces and their impact on the viewers' experience.

Smartphones in Historical Settings

One of the most glaring anachronisms in period dramas and films is the portrayal of smartphones. Characters in historical settings might be seen texting or using apps, a clear anachronism given the invention of smartphones came much later in history. This is particularly noticeable in adaptations of classic literature. For example, if a character from a 19th-century novel is depicted using a smartphone, it can create a jarring and artificial immersion break. The presence of such anachronisms can distract from the storytelling and historical authenticity.

Modern Clothing in Historical Films

Another persistent issue is the portrayal of modern clothing in historical films. In movies set in the 1800s, you may see characters wearing modern footwear or hairstyles that did not exist in that era. This is especially evident when the film's producers opt for a more contemporary aesthetic to make the story more relatable to modern audiences. However, such inaccuracies can detract from the historical accuracy and cultural authenticity of the period being portrayed, making the film feel out of place or misleading to viewers who are familiar with the historical context.

Futuristic Technology in Past Eras

The use of futuristic technology in films set in past eras is another common anachronism. Movies like Back to the Future Part II feature characters using advanced technology like hoverboards in a time period that doesn’t align with the technology's introduction in real life. This creates a stark contrast between the narrative and real-world history, making the film feel dated or surreal. Such anachronisms can be done intentionally for comedic or dramatic effect, but they often come across as jarring or sensationalist to a discerning viewer.

Digital Watches in Historical Contexts

Another prominent anachronism is the depiction of digital watches in historical contexts. In films set in the 1970s or earlier, you might spot characters wearing digital watches which were not commonly available until the late 1970s and early 1980s. This inaccuracy can be particularly jarring when the film attempts to portray a specific era in detail, as it undermines the authenticity of the setting. The use of such gadgets can make the period feel less believable and more like a modern reimagining or amalgamation of different eras.

Modern Vehicles in Period Dramas

The portrayal of modern vehicles in period dramas is another frequent anachronism. In historical dramas, you might spot modern cars or vehicles in the background, which can break the immersion of the time period being portrayed. For example, if a character is riding in a horse-drawn carriage, but there is a modern sports car in the background, it can create a sense of dissonance. Such inaccuracies can be particularly distracting in scenes that aim to portray a specific historical era in detail, as they can detract from the overall authenticity of the setting.

Contemporary Brands and Logos

Movies often feature modern brands and products in a setting decades before these companies were founded, creating anachronisms that can be jarring to viewers. For instance, you might see Coca-Cola or Apple products in a film set in the 1920s. These anachronisms serve no practical purpose and only serve to remind viewers that the film is not entirely authentic to its setting. Such branding choices may be made to appeal to contemporary audiences or simplify scenes, but they can also detract from the film's historical authenticity.

Fictional Technology That Breaks Physics

In shows like Star Trek, while the technology is meant to be futuristic, some devices, such as teleporters or warp drives, defy the laws of physics as we understand them today. These anachronisms are often done for the sake of storytelling or to provide a sense of wonder and advancement. However, such fictional technologies can create a divide between the science fiction elements and the perceived realism of the rest of the show, making the narrative feel less grounded in reality.

Inaccurate Historical Artifacts

Some shows, like Game of Thrones, feature historical artifacts or weapons that are portrayed inaccurately. For example, the use of certain types of armor or weaponry that did not exist in the depicted time or place. These anachronisms can be jarring for viewers who are familiar with the historical context and can detract from the overall authenticity of the show. While these inaccuracies might be intentional for dramatic effect, they can also make the narrative feel less believable or more confusing to a discerning audience.

Conclusion

Anachronisms in movies and TV shows can be a double-edged sword. They can serve to enhance the narrative or provide comedic relief, but they can also detract from the historical authenticity and cultural authenticity of the period being portrayed. While anachronisms can be intentional and made for creative or practical reasons, it is important for filmmakers and producers to be mindful of the historical and cultural significance of the period they are depicting. By striving for accuracy and authenticity, they can create more immersive and believable narratives that enhance the viewer's experience.