Introduction to the Controversial Finale

When it comes to analyzing John Wick 3, the discussion inevitably turns to the climax and its choices. Many arguments revolve around whether John Wick should have made certain decisions. However, one element that often gets overlooked is the final scene itself. After the intense showdown at the Continental and his triumphant victory, John faces the ultimate test. Should he rejoin the underworld or adhere to the proposal from The Adjudicator? This article explores an alternative scenario: what if the final scene in John Wick 3 played out differently, perhaps favoring a subtler conclusion?

The Current Final Scene: A Battle of Loyalties

At the climax, Wick is given a choice: obey the demands of the High Table and kill Winston, or stay loyal to his brother-in-arms by battling them. Faced with this decision, John chooses his comrade. The ensuing fight is intense and bloody, culminating in a decisive victory at the Continental. The Adjudicator proposes a parlay, and Winston accepts, securing his position. However, things take a violent turn on the rooftop when Winston tries to seize the opportunity to shift loyalty back to the High Table. John is forced to defend himself, resulting in a fierce confrontation that sees him plummet to the street after being shot multiple times. The iconic scene then shifts to the Bowery King, who rescues John and leads him to team up for revenge.

Should John Wick Fall? The Controversial Ending

However, many fans and critics feel that this end is overly dramatic and less in line with John Wick's previous style. Despite his numerous injuries, John is never shown to be seriously injured until this particular scene. The scene where he falls from the building, despite the multiple shots he receives, and survives with a few scratches, feels less realistic compared to his previous displays of superhuman endurance.

For instance, in the scene where he is shot five times off the top of a building, John's miraculous ability to simply "bounce" down like a hero, hitting a fire escape balcony and awning, is a step too far for some viewers. This moment, recorded at around 1 minute and 49 seconds in the clip, simply feels too inorganic. Had the scene ended with a more tragic and realistic outcome, the narrative could have felt more impactful and credible.

Alternative Scenarios for a More Realistic Conclusion

Instead, imagine an ending where the final gunshot proves too much for John. Imagine him, wounded and bleeding, falling to the street. In this scenario, the reality of his condition is in full view, giving the audience a more visceral and emotional experience. This would allow for a deeper exploration of the consequences of John's choices and a more palpable sense of loss and vulnerability.

The following scene could involve John being found by the Bowery King, but this time, it would not be a rescue, but rather a time of mourning. The tragedy of the situation could lead to a stronger partnership between the two characters, as they both recognize their shared pain and purpose. This would add a layer of depth to the friendship between John Wick and the Bowery King, showing a more human and relatable side of the action hero.

Conclusion: A Reshaped Finale for the Action Genre

In conclusion, the current final scene in John Wick 3 may be exciting and memorable, but it also risks alienating viewers who prefer a more grounded and realistic portrayal of action heroes. A more tragic and realistic ending, while maintaining the essence of the John Wick series, could have left a more lasting impact. This alternative scenario not only adds a layer of realism but also enhances the emotional depth of the characters and the film's overall narrative.

Given the fan base of the series and its pivotal role in the action genre, a more nuanced and impactful conclusion to John Wick 3 could have significantly increased its legacy. While the reality is that the film received critical acclaim, a subtly different ending might have solidified John Wick's place in cinema history as a more relatable, multi-dimensional character.