An In-depth Analysis of 'Dragon Ball Super' Manga vs Anime

Introduction

Dragon Ball Super is one of the most anticipated continuations of the Dragon Ball saga, captivating audiences with its blend of action, excitement, and character growth. While it has gained a massive fan base, there are differing opinions on how well the manga performs as compared to the anime. In this article, we delve into a detailed analysis, comparing the two mediums and examining the nuances that set them apart.

Power Scaling and Battle Dynamics: Manga vs Anime

One of the notable differences between the manga and the anime lies in the way power scaling and battle dynamics are handled. Many argue that the manga offers a more strategic and nuanced approach to these elements.

For instance, the manga showcases Goku using the Super Saiyan God (SSG) form more strategically, as seen in various instances where Goku transitions between forms to gauge the power levels of his opponents. This strategic power usage is better reflected in the manga compared to the anime, where transitions are often abrupt. Some key examples include:

Using SSG against Hit in the manga, illustrating a more methodical power assessment. Goku’s use of SSG against Goku Black in the manga, demonstrating a more measured approach rather than instantly switching to the Blue form. Transitioning from SSJ3 to SSG and then to SSB in battles, providing insight into the evolving dynamics of the fight.

These techniques offer a more robust depiction of Goku and Vegeta’s strategic thinking and power management during battles.

Character Development and Emotional Impact: Manga vs Anime

The manga provides a richer, more emotionally engaging experience for fans. Several arcs in the manga are praised for their depth and character development:

In the Dragon Ball Super manga, Goku is often shown to be more reflective and strategic. For example, in the Universe 6 arc, Goku’s defeat of Toppo is more than just a battle—he is tasked with saving the universe, making the victory feel more significant. This arc provides a clearer rationale for the use of Super Saiyan God (SSG), making it more impactful.

Similarly, the Future Trunks arc is more engaging in the manga. It gives Trunks healing powers and provides Vegeta with a compelling reason to fuse with Goku, enhancing the stakes and drama of the scene. However, it also leaves Trunks feeling somewhat useless, which is a nuanced portrayal that differs from the anime where he is more proactive.

The inclusion of Goku Black is another area where the manga excels over the anime. In the manga, Goku Black is portrayed as a one-dimensional, egotistical character, making his victory over Goku in the anime feel less satisfying. Instead, the manga version of Goku Black throws temper tantrums and reacts with temper when Vegeta gives him a smile, adding a layer of relatability and making his presence more impactful.

Weaknesses and Criticisms: Manga vs Anime

Despite the strengths, the manga also has its shortcomings. Some critics argue that certain arcs, such as Bo blowjob (BBI) and ROF, are too short or lack depth. Additionally, the handling of certain characters and storylines can be seen as problematic:

The BBI arc, for instance, is considered too rushed and poorly executed. It felt like an afterthought and did not provide enough value to warrant its inclusion. Similarly, the ROF (Robotic Oxygen Forced) arc is skipped entirely in the manga, which can be seen as a missed opportunity to further develop the plot. The Universe 6 arc, however, adds to the depth of Vegeta’s character, making his defeat more justified and the SSG form more relevant.

The Future Trunks arc, while better than the anime in some respects, can feel underdeveloped. The manga portrays Future Trunks as somewhat useless, which is a departure from the anime where he plays a more active role in the story. This nuance adds a layer of complexity but can be seen as a missed opportunity for character growth.

Conclusion

Overall, while the manga offers a more strategic and nuanced approach to power scaling and battle dynamics, it also falls short in certain areas, such as handling weak arcs and underdeveloping characters. Fans and critics alike appreciate the manga's focus on depth and character development, but it is not without its flaws. The anime, on the other hand, provides a more action-packed experience, albeit with some less impactful moments.

Whether the manga or anime is superior depends largely on the viewer's preference. Both mediums offer unique and engaging experiences, and it's worth exploring both to form a balanced opinion.