An In-Depth Analysis: Which 2016 Animated Disney Film Do You Prefer?

When discussing the 2016 animated films from Disney, opinions vary widely. Personally, Moana reigns supreme, with Zootropolis coming in at a close second. While Finding Dory failed to make a lasting impact, all three films are noteworthy, though some aspects are questionable.

The Standing of Moana in the 2016 Disney Lineup

Coming in at the top is clearly Moana. Despite not being perfect, it stands out as one of the last genuinely good Disney films in recent years. The heroine's journey, lush visuals, and the themes explored all contribute to a compelling story. While I personally found the name “Moana” to be a bit unappealing, the film as a whole resonates with viewers in a profound way. The hidden destiny of the heroine, the unfounded fear of her tribe, and the reveal that the feared enemy and patron goddess are two sides of the same entity all add to the rich plot development.

The visual elements are also noteworthy. The vibrant blues and stunning landscapes created by Disney are a feast for the eyes, truly adding to the immersive experience. And let’s not forget the spot-on portrayal provided by Dwayne Johnson as the demigod with a tragic past. However, even in Moana, there are minor issues, such as the overly complex subplot involving the fish hook, which could have been better integrated. But overall, it was a very enjoyable and engaging movie.

Reflecting on Zootropolis

Zootropolis comes in at a close second. While it might have been slightly overhyped, it remains a standout film. The movie shines through its well-developed characters and engaging plot. The moral and social issues it addresses are thought-provoking, and the portrayal of friendship and acceptance is heartwarming. Although the antagonist in the film is well-defined, the overall plot remains somewhat convoluted. The fundamental flaw lies in the reliance on the serum as a plot device, which brings out the inner predator in predators, along with the oversimplified character dynamics.

The story revolves around a coyote who dreams of becoming a police officer despite societal limitations. This dream eventually leads to the discovery of corruption in the city. While the film is strongly characterized, with exceptional performances from the cast, including Jason Bateman as the chief of the police department, the plot revolves around complex thematic ideas such as prejudice and acceptance, making it an engaging watch for all ages.

Disappointments with Finding Dory

Finding Dory was a significant letdown. Owing to its predecessor, Finding Nemo, which was a monumental success, viewers had high expectations for this spin-off. However, it falls short in many areas. The reliance on the reunion with parents as a plot device is utilized to add emotional weight to the narrative, but it feels formulaic. The writing for Ellen DeGeneres's character is particularly disappointing, as her role in Dory's journey lacks depth and nuance. The focus on the origin story of Dory, while touching, overshadows the emotional journey she might have taken.

The film also attempts to sneak in a convoluted subplot about Dory finding a trail of shells in the vast Pacific Ocean, which is impractical and lacks believability. The question arises: how many thousands of miles across is the Pacific Ocean, and what are the odds of finding a shell trail? Such plot elements ring false and detract from the overall storyline. Despite this, Ellen DeGeneres's performance remains a highlight, providing both humor and warmth to the film.

Conclusion: A Tale of Three Films

In conclusion, while Moana and Zootropolis top the list in terms of quality and impact, Finding Dory ultimately fails to live up to the standard set by its predecessors. Each film offers a unique blend of humor, adventure, and emotional depth, catering to different audiences. But if we had to choose, the plot and thematic resonance of Moana edge out Zootropolis slightly, making it the top choice for many viewers.

Moving forward, these films serve as a testament to the enduring appeal of Disney animation, each bringing its own strengths to the table. Whether you prefer the deep dive into society through the lens of animals in Zootropolis, the mystical and thrilling adventure of Moana, or the touching journey of a lost fish named Dory, there is undoubtedly something for every viewer in these 2016 Disney classics.