An Analysis of the Red Fort Incident: Who Should Bear the Blame?

The Red Fort Incident on Republic Day in 2021 is a complex event with multiple stakeholders involved. While Kisan leaders were adamant in organizing a tractor march, their actions and the involvement of various groups beyond their control contributed to the conflicts. This article explores the roles of different parties and analyzes who should be held responsible for the ensuing events.

The Roles of Different Groups

The incident on Red Fort on 26th January can be attributed to a variety of actors:

1. Middlemen and False Farmers

One of the critical factors in this incident was the presence of middlemen masquerading as farmers. These individuals often organize protests and use the guise of farmers to mobilize support and hide their true intentions. They were joined by various supporters, including hierarchical activists like Yogendra Yadav, who play pivotal roles in driving these movements. Additionally, unbiased neutral views and YouTube channels that falsely claim to present unbiased information further fueled the situation.

2. Lethal Media Channels

The involvement of media channels labeled luthayan channels played a significant role in shaping public opinion and exacerbating the situation. These outlets often sensationalize events and skew information to serve their agendas, which contributed to the tension and violence during the tractor march.

3. Political Actors and Opposition

The Indian opposition parties, particularly the Indian National Congress (INC) and the Aam Aadmi Party (AAP), capitalized on the situation for political gains. They criticized the government and blamed it for not preventing the violence, even though they were not actively involved in the initial planning and organization of the protest.

4. Law Enforcement and Government Authorities

The Delhi Police and the Union Home Ministry were also at fault for their handling of the situation. The decision to allow the tractor march to take place on Republic Day, a day of national importance, was seen as a careless mistake. The police, under the control of Amit Shah, resorted to indiscriminate lathi charges, which caused further resentment among the farmers and contributed to the resulting violence.

Khalistani Organizations and Their Role

Another significant aspect of the Red Fort Incident was the involvement of Khalistani organizations. Groups such as Sikhs for Justice, ISI, and Vampanthi liberals were instrumental in destabilizing the peaceful protest and exacerbating the situation. Their actions contributed to the chaos and violence that ensued.

Failures in Responsibility

Ultimately, the responsibility falls on multiple parties. Farmers' unions bear some responsibility for not adequately managing their rallies and ensuring peaceful protests. However, the government, the police, and the farmers' unions collectively failed to maintain peace. The government and the police were particularly irresponsible for allowing the tractor march to proceed, risking a potentially violent situation on a national holiday. This decision showed a lack of foresight and a disregard for public safety.

In conclusion, while the kisan leaders had a significant role in organizing the protest, their failure to prevent violence cannot be solely blamed on them. The government and law enforcement authorities must also take responsibility for mishandling the situation and allowing it to deteriorate into chaos.