Introduction: A New Dawn for Westeros

Imagine a different Westeros, a peaceful and united realm under the rule of King Rhaegar Targaryen. In this alternate reality, several key characters survive and the events of the series take a vastly different path. This article explores the ramifications of the survival of Joanna Lannister, Steffon Baratheon, and Rickard Stark. What if they had lived, and how would their survival change the narrative of Westeros?

Steffon Baratheon's Rule and Legacy

In this alternate world, Steffon Baratheon remains the Lord of the Stormlands and holds a position directly in line for the Iron Throne. His survival alleviates the immediate threat of a potential succession plot if things get complicated. If everything remains stable, Steffon can be seated as king. However, if the political landscape shifts, he would be a valuable bargaining chip. Steffon being alive also implies that he found a Valyrian wife for Rhaegar, thus avoiding the marriage between Elia Martell and Rhaegar Targaryen. The question remains: Who might he marry instead? It is possible that Stannis Baratheon or Edmure Tully could marry Elia.

Joanna Lannister's Impact on King's Landing

Survival of Joanna Lannister would have a significant impact on Tyrion Lannister. She would not have been as harshly treated by her father, Tywin Lannister. Consequently, the separation of the twins and Tyrion's escalation to cruel treatment might not have occurred in the same fashion. It is intriguing to consider whether Joanna might have orchestrated the marriage between Cersei Lannister and Oberyn Martell to remove Rhaegar as an option for marriage. This action could have prevented Jamie Lannister from joining the Kingsguard and marrying Lysa Arryn. The narrative would be altered by the influence and decision-making abilities of Joanna, whose presence could have softened the strict rule and brutality of Tywin Lannister.

Robert Baratheon's Exit from the Eyrie

The survival of Rickard Stark introduces a different dynamic. Robert Baratheon, who was meant to come from the Eyrie to confront his father, would instead be shown what his true position within the family is by his father, Steffon Baratheon. This interaction could foster a more unified northern front against the Mad King. Additionally, Stannis Baratheon would possibly be more understanding and less bitter due to not seeing his parents die, potentially easing his feelings of resentment and making him a more cooperative individual in the council. This scenario could have prevented Brandon Stark from going to King's Landing to demand Rhaegar's death, as Tywin might have approached the situation with diplomacy and promised to find Lyanna Stark.

Alternative Coup and Lyanna's Reign

If Rhaegar Targaryen remains unmarried and still looking for Lyanna Stark, he would either marry Ashara Dayne, the sister of House Mace Tyrell, or Lysa Tully. Lysa would provide a stronger alliance due to her family connections. Given her legendary beauty and the prince's status, it is reasonable to believe Lysa would be happier in such a marriage. The marriage between Rhaegar and Lyanna would also have significant implications for the line of succession. If they have children, the Targaryen lineage might be restored through Lyanna, providing a powerful new direction for the kingdom. If Rhaegar has only daughters, the throne would likely pass to Viserys, leading to a possible split as Rhaegar's daughters try to prevent their uncle from taking power.

Daenerys's Fate and the Wall

In our altered history, Daenerys Targaryen would never have been born, leaving the Wall to remain intact. Consequently, the threat of dragons and the eventual war with the Night King would be averted, leading to a markedly different political and social landscape. The survival of these key figures could potentially avert the rebellion against the Mad King, as there would be no pressing reason for such a drastic action.