Alternative Paths for Ben Solo: What if He Remained a Jedi?

Ben Solo, a character from the Star Wars universe, is known for his dramatic turn to the Dark Side, which dramatically shaped the course of the story. However, what if he had chosen differently? This article explores the alternative paths Ben might have taken if he remained a Jedi under the teachings of Luke Skywalker.

Ben's Early Journey

Before delving into the alternative paths, it is crucial to understand Ben's early training and his divergence from the Jedi path. Ben was originally trained as a Jedi but was ultimately seduced by the Force's dark side, leading to his transformation. His journey to the Dark Side is marked by mental and emotional instability, making him a formidable but erratic adversary.

Supreme Leader and Sith Emperor

If Ben remained as Supreme Leader and continued to cultivate the dark side, he would have undoubtedly joined the final battle. In this scenario, he would have either attempted to eliminate Poe and Finn or worked with Palpatine to incite Rey to claim her birthright as Empress. Such actions would have led to a catastrophic outcome for the Resistance, setting the stage for more turmoil in the galaxy.

Continuing Luke's Jedi School

Alternatively, if Luke had not resorted to drastic measures, such as nearly killing Ben, he might have taken a different approach. Luke would have sat down with Ben to discuss the greatness of the Light side, emphasizing the importance of balance and compassion. This approach could have included:

Exploring the emotional and psychological factors that led Ben to the Dark Side. Introducing Ben to new Jedi teachings and practices to reinforce the Light side. Building a stronger bond between Ben and his mentor, Luke.

Even if Rey had initially resisted Palpatine's influence, the Sith Lord would likely have continued to manipulate her until she embraced her birthright. The final confrontation would have pitted Palpatine against Rey, with Ben and Luke facing each other in a pivotal duel. At the last moment, Rey, having endured years of abuse and torture, would turn against Palpatine and strike him down, ultimately preserving the Force in the galaxy.

Rebuilding the Jedi Order

In this scenario, Luke would have taken Rey under his wing to continue her training in the dark side, much like Ben. Luke's teachings would prepare Rey to take on her role as a Jedi and eventually as Ben's apprentice. This partnership would be crucial in rebuilding the Jedi Order and ensuring the continuation of the Light side.

Conclusion

The fate of Ben Solo is a complex one, with many possible paths he could have taken. Whether as a Supreme Leader in the Dark, or as a Jedi trainee under Luke's guidance, each path would have significant consequences for the galaxy. By exploring these different scenarios, we can gain a deeper understanding of the forces that shape characters in the Star Wars universe and the importance of the choices they make.