Alternative History: The Impact of Tyrion and Jaime’s Death on Westeros

Imagine a world where Lysa Tully and Catelyn Stark kill both Tyrion Lannister and Jaime Lannister instead of releasing them. What would have happened then? This article explores the far-reaching consequences of such an alternate timeline, focusing on the immediate reactions of major characters and the eventual impact on the political landscape of Westeros.

Public Reaction and Tyrion’s Death

The public's reaction to Tyrion’s death would be varied. Most people might not care significantly about his demise, given his physical stature as a dwarf. However, Tywin Lannister would certainly act outraged and vow vengeance for the disgrace to House Lannister. In private, I suspect Tywin would feel a sense of relief. Cersei, ever the drama queen, would be overjoyed and would ensure everyone knew about her elation.

Publicly, some might hold a token funeral and put on a show of mourning for a brief period. However, Cersei would revel in the news and parade her joy for all to see.

Jaime’s Response and Ned Stark’s Fate

Jaime, one of Tyrion’s few family members who truly loved him, would likely react differently if Tyrion were killed. The incident in King's Landing where Jaime killed Ned's guards and broke Ned’s leg would be mirrored in this scenario. Jaime might well ensure that Ned did not survive the scuffle. With Ned dead, the political landscape would shift drastically. Jaime’s capture as he did in the original storyline would be unlikely, as Ned’s presence would not be a factor anymore.

Catelyn Stark, known for her loyalty to her family, would not have Jaime killed. Her sanity might be pushed to the brink, but even she would have reservations about killing a member of her own family. After all, Catelyn always made decisions to protect her family, even if they were questionable.

Political and Military Implications

The absence of both Tyrion and Jaime would significantly alter the dynamics of the war. With Ned Stark’s death occurring earlier, the war would break out even earlier than in the original storyline. Robert Baratheon, still alive in this scenario, would be unlikely to align himself with the Lannisters over the Starks. Ironically, the Starks might have a better chance in this alternate timeline.

The Lannisters, already facing internal turmoil, would be severely crippled. Tywin, a man of pragmatism, would most likely ensure the safety of Joffrey, Tommen, and Myrcella and make a dash for King’s Landing. Kevan or Steffon could hold Casterly Rock effectively, eliminating the need for complex logistical strategies and maneuvering for power.

The Starks might face more immediate threats but could still satisfy their bannermen. The Vale, under Lysa Tully’s leadership, would remain neutral as the Eyrie’s impenetrable defenses and Lysa’s lack of interest in the war kept them uninvolved.

Final Confrontation at the Battle of Blackwater

The eventual fate of Westeros would depend on the outcome of the battle between Tywin Lannister and Stannis Baratheon. In this scenario, Tywin, with the loss of both his sons, would focus on securing his remaining family’s safety. The battle’s outcome would determine the future of both houses, with significant implications for the realm as a whole.

Conclusion

This alternate history presents a different timeline where Tyrion and Jaime’s death would have profound effects on Westeros. From the immediate reactions of key characters to the broader implications for the ongoing battles and the political landscape, the consequences of such an event would be far-reaching. The story of Westeros has many twists and turns, and even the loss of two important characters could dramatically alter the course of events.