Alternate Betrothals for Lyanna Stark: Howland Reed, Mark Ryswell, or William Dustin

The proposition of Lyanna Stark being betrothed to someone other than Rhaegar Targaryen—such as Howland Reed, Mark Ryswell, or William Dustin—would dramatically alter the political landscape and character dynamics in A Song of Ice and Fire. Each of these scenarios would introduce distinct changes, from the re-shaping of political alliances to the evolution of the characters' relationships and arcs. Let us delve deeper into each of these alternate scenarios.

Lyanna betrothed to Howland Reed

Political Implications: Howland Reed is the lord of Greywater Watch and a close ally of House Stark. A betrothal to him would strengthen the ties between the Starks and the Reeds, potentially leading to a closer alliance in the North. Greywater Watch, a strategic position in the Crow's Isle, would provide the Starks with an additional stronghold. Such an alliance would ensure that the Starks have a more robust network in the east, making them better equipped to deal with threats from both the south and the east.

Impact on the Rebellion: With Lyanna not taken by Rhaegar, the events leading to Robert's Rebellion may have unfolded differently. The "kidnapping" narrative, which fueled much of the animosity between the Starks and the Baratheons towards the Targaryens, would have been absent. This could potentially delay or even prevent the rebellion. The absence of this catalyst could have fragmented the Lannister-Targaryen alliance, leading to a protracted and perhaps less lethal military confrontation between the Starks and the Lannisters.

Character Dynamics: Howland Reed is known for his wisdom and secrecy. A marriage to Lyanna might result in a more strategic approach to Northern politics, focusing on alliances rather than outright conflict. This alliance would necessitate the Starks to navigate diplomatic challenges and maintain a delicate balance of power in the North. Lyanna, with Howland's guidance, could become a significant political figure, leveraging her status to protect her family and the people of the North.

Lyanna betrothed to Mark Ryswell

Political Implications: House Ryswell is a lesser house in the North, so a betrothal to Mark would not carry the same weight as one to a more prominent house. This could signify a shift in alliances, but it might also render Lyanna's potential political influence weaker. While Mark Ryswell is a respected man, his status as a lesser lord would not provide the same strategic advantages as a more prominent alliance.

Impact on the Rebellion: If Lyanna were to marry Mark, her absence as a catalyst for Robert's Rebellion would likely mean the conflict unfolds differently. The Ryswells may not have the resources or influence to rally support against the Targaryens effectively. This would mean a more subdued rebellion, possibly without the same fervor or urgency. The absence of Lyanna's tragic narrative could mean a different perspective on the rebellion, making it a lesser-known chapter in the history of Westeros.

Character Dynamics: Mark Ryswell is less prominent in the narrative, so Lyanna's character arc might not have the same impact on the story. She might lead a quieter life, potentially focusing on domestic matters rather than becoming a figure of legend. This would mean a different trajectory for her character, shifting the focus from the intense political and romantic tensions to more personal and domestic issues.

Lyanna betrothed to William Dustin

Political Implications: William Dustin hails from a noble house with a strong reputation. A betrothal to him could enhance the Stark-Dustin ties, leading to a more unified North. As a well-respected and strong house, William and his family would provide the Starks with significant political and military support. This alliance would be crucial in ensuring the stability of the North, especially in light of the Targaryen threat.

Impact on the Rebellion: Similar to the other scenarios, if Lyanna were married to William, the romantic tension with Rhaegar would not exist. This could lead to a more stable political situation. However, issues such as the Duskendale incident and the ensuing tensions with the Targaryens might still provoke unrest. The conflict with House Reyne and the events at Summerhall would likely still occur, but the political landscape might be less tumultuous due to the absence of the "catalyst" of Lyanna's presence and disappearance.

Character Dynamics: William is portrayed as a pragmatic character and his marriage to Lyanna could lead to a different type of partnership emphasizing loyalty and duty over romance. This partnership would be more about mutual support and strategic alliances rather than the intense romantic and political drama. Lyanna might be seen more as a noblewoman, fulfilling her duties and responsibilities, rather than a tragic figure. Her character arc would focus more on her role as a political figure, contributing to the stability and unity of the North.

Conclusion

In all these scenarios, the absence of Lyanna's relationship with Rhaegar would fundamentally alter the events leading to Robert's Rebellion and the subsequent power struggles in Westeros. Each alternative betrothal would create different alliances, motivations, and outcomes, ultimately leading to a very different political landscape in the North and beyond. The Starks, with these alternative betrothals, would face different challenges and opportunities, shaping the narrative and the history of Westeros in unique and compelling ways.