Why Are Prometheus and Covenant Fall Short in Comparison to the Original Alien?

When it comes to the Alien franchise, two particular entries, Prometheus and Covenant, often receive criticism for failing to live up to the standards set by the original films. This article delves into why these films may disappoint fans who are hoping for meaningful continuations in the legacy of the classic horror series.

1. Expectations vs. Reality

Prometheus, as a prequel to the iconic Alien franchise, was highly anticipated by fans. However, the film's narrative and tone did not meet these expectations. Many viewers felt that the movie was more about disappointment than it was about delivering a satisfying backstory. The focus on deep philosophical themes and existential dread did not resonate with audiences who were in search of more straightforward horror elements. This disconnect between the expectations and the reality of what the film provided led to a sense of letdown among fans of the original Alien series.

2. Character Development

Both Prometheus and Covenant have faced criticism for their character development. In Prometheus, the characters lacked depth and complexity, making it difficult for the audience to connect with them on an emotional level. Covenant was no better, featuring underdeveloped protagonists that failed to inspire genuine interest or investment. This lack of character development significantly hampered the overall effectiveness of these films, leaving fans wanting more nuanced, three-dimensional characters.

3. Plot and Pacing Issues

The plots of Prometheus and Covenant have been described as convoluted and confusing. While both films attempted to weave complex narratives, they often felt disjointed and poorly paced. The pacing issues in Prometheus, in particular, were noted for dragging the storyline towards a finale that did not do justice to the ambitious premise set up. In Covenant, the plot twists and turns were so random and illogical that they detracted from the horror and suspense that defined the original franchise. This makes the films less engaging and more frustrating for viewers who prefer a tighter, more cohesive narrative.

4. Tone and Themes

The philosophical themes explored in both Prometheus and Covenant, such as the nature of creation and the role of artificial intelligence, were divisive among audiences. Some appreciated the depth and intellectual stimulation provided by these films, while others felt that these themes detracted from the horror elements that made the original Alien films so terrifying. This duality in reception can be seen as a failure to strike a balance that would satisfy both deep thinkers and fans of visceral thrills.

5. Alien Franchise Expectations

Fans of the original Alien franchise entered Prometheus and Covenant hoping for a return to the straightforward and thrilling horror that defined the classics. However, the ambitious storytelling and complex plotlines often felt like a misstep. The films' attempts to delve into deeper themes and explore the origins of the Xenomorphs resulted in a narrative that was less cohesive and less scary than the original trilogy. This disappointment can be intensified by the fact that the franchise has never really matched the same level of intensity and suspense as the original films.

Conclusion

While there is no denying that both Prometheus and Covenant presented interesting concepts, their execution often fell short of the mark. The ambition of the stories did not resonate with some fans who preferred the more straightforward horror of the earlier films. Despite the intentions behind these films, the results can be seen as a letdown for many fans who were looking for a return to the classic formula. Fans must weigh the philosophical depth these films offer against the formulas that made the original Alien franchise so iconic.