A Star Trek Comparison: Original Series vs Discovery

For decades, the Star Trek universe has captivated fans across generations. Two significant entries in its vast library are Star Trek: The Original Series (TOS) and Star Trek: Discovery (ST:D). Airing decades apart, these series have distinct characteristics and followings. But which one reigns supreme? In this article, we explore the nuances of both, highlighting why Star Trek enthusiasts harbor deep love and loyalty to each series. Let’s dive into the heart of the debate between Star Trek: Discovery and Star Trek: The Original Series.

Star Trek: The Original Series

Introduction to TOS

When I was in my teens, my first exposure to Star Trek was through Star Trek: The Original Series (TOS). This groundbreaking series, which aired from 1966 to 1969, was a revolutionary take on space exploration and interstellar adventure. The show was known for its profound exploration of moral and philosophical issues, its timeless character arcs, and its iconic portrayal of Captain James T. Kirk, his first officer Spock, and the rest of the USS Enterprise crew.

Special Effects and Viewing Experience

While today's special effects might leave TOS feeling dated, it’s important to recognize the limitations of the production technology available at the time. Despite these limitations, the production team managed to create a universe that was both imaginative and visually appealing. The choice of matte paintings, models, and practical effects not only added to the authenticity of the series but also gave it a unique charm that endears it to fans even today.

Star Trek: Discovery

Introduction to ST:D

When my sixties rolled around, I was introduced to Star Trek: Discovery (ST:D). This more recent series, which began streaming in 2017, presented a new era of Star Trek with a fresh perspective and approach. Unlike TOS, ST:D was designed for contemporary audiences, utilizing advanced special effects and a broader scope, including more diverse characters and storylines that span multiple centuries.

Adoption and Appreciation

Adoption Perceptions

When ST:D first appeared, it took time for me to adjust to the new format. New shows often face resistance from long-term fans who prefer the established tropes and aesthetics of earlier series. However, as my relationship with Star Trek deepened, I found myself appreciating the new direction that ST:D took. The show's dedication to creating a rich, inter-connected narrative across its seasons was a testament to the efforts of its producers to enhance the overall storytelling of the franchise.

Key Elements and Enjoyment

One of the standout features of ST:D is its ability to introduce more complex and nuanced storylines. The show doesn't shy away from exploring darker themes or flawed characters, which adds depth and realism to the narrative. Additionally, the use of advanced visual effects, especially in its most recent series, makes it visually compelling and enjoyable to watch.

Personal Preferences and Nostalgia

Comparative Suitability

It’s challenging to make a true comparison between the two series, as they were created in different eras with vastly different technologies and artistic philosophies. This has led to fan debates centered around the relative quality and appeal of each series. However, it's worth noting that every fan has a different preference and nostalgia factor that influences their viewing experience.

My Stance

As a longtime Star Trek fan, I cherish both series. TOS holds a special place in my heart, not only because of its groundbreaking content but also because it was there at the beginning of my journey as a Trekkie. On the other hand, ST:D has earned its place through its innovative storytelling, broader scope, and the excellent performances of its cast. While I may personally prefer the narrative and character development of TOS, I also find immense satisfaction in the compelling fight scene choreography and the deeply engaging plot twists of ST:D.

The Star Trek Legacy

Understanding the Influences

Both Star Trek: The Original Series and Star Trek: Discovery are essential parts of the vast Star Trek legacy. Each contributes to the richness and diversity of the franchise's storytelling. The Original Series established the norms, the very trademarks of the Star Trek franchise, while Discovery pushed the boundaries with its innovative storytelling and character development.

Conclusion

Regardless of which series I prefer, the enduring appeal of Star Trek lies in its ability to inspire and engage audiences across generations. Whether you are a die-hard fan of TOS or someone who has joined the Star Trek community through Discovery, there is something compelling about exploring the vast universe of starships and alien encounters that Star Trek has to offer.