A Comprehensive Analysis of Zack Snyder's Justice League and the 2017 Release

Has Zack Snyder's Justice League (often referred to as the Snyder Cut) captured your attention? Many fans are divided on this critically acclaimed but controversial film. This article delves into the differences between the 2017 release and the Snyder Cut, offering a detailed comparison and a variety of perspectives.

Overview of Zack Snyder's Justice League

The Snyder Cut, named after its director, Zack Snyder, has garnered significant attention for its unique storyline and character development. Unlike the 2017 release, this version involves a more cohesive narrative and an enhanced exploration of the DC Extended Universe (DCEU).

Comparison with 2017 Release

Storyline and Engagement

For some, the Snyder Cut is superior:

It is a more engaging and coherent story, leading to a better narrative arc. It introduces and develops the characters in a more nuanced and consistent manner. It sets the foundation for future DCEU films and series, much like how The Watchman and the planned new season for The Watchman would connect with one another.

However, others find it super boring and nonsensical, as one reviewer puts it. The story seems disjointed and juvenile, which might be attributed to certain creative choices, such as the absence of Darkseid as the main villain.

Superman and the Ships

One of the most discussed aspects of the Snyder Cut is the inconsistency in the storyline involving Superman. In Man of Steel, Superman is seen shrugging off Steppenwolf's ax without any pain, which he does again in the Snyder Cut. This choice might be justified by the fact that both films are part of the DCEU continuity. However, there are other inconsistencies, such as the appearance of two Superman ships, which raises questions about the timeline and story logic.

For instance, in Man of Steel, Zod steals the "Superman Ship" from the Arctic and crashes it in Metropolis. In the Snyder Cut, there is another ship in Metropolis, and a new one in the Arctic. Where did this second ship come from? This plot hole is significant, as it disrupts the narrative and logical consistency of the film.

Critical Perspectives and Personal Opinions

Some viewers, including the author, appreciate the Snyder Cut for what it is. Despite personal upset, it is acknowledged as a better film compared to the 2017 release. The Snyder Cut offers stronger extensions of the story, making it a solid entry in the DCEU, much like a potential series that could build upon the characters and events introduced in the film.

The Snyder Cut also challenges the status quo of the DCEU, asking viewers to consider what other content could have been available if the universe was unimpeded, such as a similar approach to filmes like The Watchman.

Conclusion

Whether you prefer the Snyder Cut or the 2017 release of Justice League, both films have their merits and flaws. Fans are encouraged to explore both versions to form their own opinions. The Snyder Cut is a fascinating take on the DC characters, offering a more cohesive and nuanced narrative that could set a new standard for the DCEU.