A Comparative Analysis of TMNT Animated Series: 1987, 2003, 2012, and 2018

Introduction

When it comes to choosing the best Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (TMNT) animated series, opinions vary widely. While some fans hold the original 1987 series in high regard, others claim the 2003 series to be the absolute best. In this article, we will delve into the merits of each series, specifically the 1987, 2003, 2012, and 2018 editions, and provide insights into why the 2003 series stands out as the top choice.

1987 Series

The 1987 series, a creation that first aired on syndicated television, is often lauded for its inimitable art style and dynamic character designs. However, it has its drawbacks. While it introduced a dark and scarier edge that would appeal to older children, it also faced criticism for mindless gags and repetitive episodes. Additionally, the show was co-created by Peter Laird, who stated that he and his partner Kevin Eastman were largely ignored after the first year, leading to the show's declining quality.

2003 Series

The 2003 series is widely regarded as the savior of the TMNT franchise. This series, which aired between 2003 and 2009, restored the series to a level of popularity and cultural impact that had been lost since the 1987 series. The 2003 run saw Peter Laird personally overseeing the script drafts, ensuring that the characters and storylines were authentic to the original source material.

One of the standout features of the 2003 series is the complex and evolving character development. Each character is portrayed with depth and complexity, showing significant growth and change throughout the series. As a fan of this series, I can attest to the feeling of anticipation and suspense as cliffhangers left viewers eagerly waiting for the next episode. The series also planned out its finale in advance, producing a satisfying conclusion, which distinguishes it from the other series.

2012 Series

The 2012 series, though well-intentioned, falls short against the 2003 run. This series, which aired from 2012 to 2013, aimed to revisit the original 1987 premise but stumbled in several critical areas. Firstly, the episodes felt very episodic and lacked a cohesive narrative flow. Secondly, the characters did not undergo significant development, with minimal changes in their behavior or relationships.

The 2012 series also faced criticism for its uneven storytelling and lack of a clear arc. The pacing and consistency of the series were hampered by the creators' uncertainty about its future, making it feel like a rushed and unfinished project.

2018 Series

The 2018 series, while technically a continuation of the show, is far from a classic. It was criticized heavily for its short lifespan and its lack of depth and substance. The series was intended to be a three-season run but was canceled after 2.5 seasons, rendering it relatively unpopular and forgettable.

Conclusion

In summary, while each TMNT animated series has its unique qualities, the 2003 series stands head and shoulders above the rest. With its expertly crafted characters, complex storylines, and meaningful character development, it undeniably sets the standard for TMNT animated series.

br /br /Keywords: TMNT 1987, TMNT 2003, TMNT 2012, TMNT 2018br /br /Back to Top