A Classic Comparison: The Sound of Music vs. The Wizard of Oz

When it comes to choosing between two iconic classic movies, The Sound of Music and The Wizard of Oz, it's a rather tough decision for many. Both films hold a special place in the hearts of movie-goers of all ages, but as we grow older, our preferences often shift. Here, I will explore my personal journey with these films and why I lean towards The Wizard of Oz.

Personal Preferences: From Childhood to Adulthood

As a child, I fell in love with both The Sound of Music and The Wizard of Oz. However, as I grew older and watched them multiple times, my feelings have remained unchanged. Both movies continue to be favorites, but my recent reflections have led me to conclude that I now prefer The Wizard of Oz. This preference is primarily due to the emotional impact each movie has on me.

When I was a child, The Wizard of Oz was an annual must-watch on TV, a holiday event that brought the entire family together. The magical journey of Dorothy, the awakenings of the Scarecrow, Tin Man, and Lion, and the memorable characters made this film a timeless classic for me. Even seeing it on the big screen as an adult brought new layers of appreciation. Despite being from 1939, the film's special effects have aged incredibly well, and it still holds up as a wonderful movie for all ages.

Comparing Storytelling and Themes

While both films are great musicals, the storytelling and themes in The Wizard of Oz make it stand out to me. The journey of Dorothy and her companions is one of discovery and self-realization. The characters learn that their true qualities are what make them great. This theme resonates deeply and provides a message that is both relatable and inspiring.

In contrast, The Sound of Music offers romance, suspense, and comedy, which are enjoyable elements but perhaps not as profound as the themes in The Wizard of Oz. The movie’s portrayal of the Captain von Trapp and his children is far from the reality. The film transforms him into a stern figure and Maria into a loving guide, while in reality, the Captain was very loving, and Maria was the strict disciplinarian. This divergence from the truth may be why I find the movie a bit hoakie.

Conclusion and Reflection

Both The Sound of Music and The Wizard of Oz are incredible films based on books. However, the version of The Wizard of Oz feels more faithful to the original story and has a better balance between plot and character development. The Sound of Music, while still an exceptional movie, takes some liberties with the story, altering the portrayal of characters and events.

While both films are great, the Wizard of Oz is the clear choice for me. It’s not just the magic and fantasy that makes it superior; it’s the profound themes and relatable messages that resonate on a personal level. So, whether you’re a true fan of The Sound of Music or The Wizard of Oz, I encourage you to watch them both again and see if your preference has shifted over time.

Both these movies are more than just classic films; they are beloved stories that offer timeless lessons and joy. Whether it’s the journey of Dorothy or the beautiful story of the von Trapp family, they are both treasures that deserve to be revisited and cherished.

Keywords: The Sound of Music, The Wizard of Oz, classic movies